Deep Purple Fan Forum :: Rapture Of The Deep :: Close This Whole Thread? ~ Runboard

Deep Purple Fan Forum
Rapture Of The Deep
Close This Whole Thread? (Sticky)

SixtyNine
Purple fan
Global user

Registered: 10-2005
Posts: 722

Reply | Quote

Close This Whole Thread?

Don't you think it's about time to close this "ROTD" thread? It's been almost a year since the album was released. Most of us keep on telling same stories. I believe all good and bad that could be said about the album has been already said emoticon

17/8/2006, 16:39

Send Email to SixtyNine Send PM to SixtyNine

Fuzz Box
Banned user
Global user

Registered: 05-2006
Posts: 67

Reply | Quote

Re: Close This Whole Thread?

No. Keep it open, I haven't made my mind up as to wether I like the album or not yet. emoticon

17/8/2006, 19:36

Send Email to Fuzz Box Send PM to Fuzz Box

Star City
Purple fan
Global user

Registered: 11-2005
Posts: 729

Reply | Quote

Re: Close This Whole Thread?

I agree with sixtynine....it's time to bid a fond farewell to this thread...

18/8/2006, 20:42

Send Email to Star City Send PM to Star City

paice30
Purple fan
Global user

Registered: 07-2005
Posts: 388

Reply | Quote

Re: Close This Whole Thread?

I had a weak argument as to why to keep it open ... but decided I didn't have the onions to keep it on.

Why not keep it open?

Last edited by paice30, 19/8/2006, 2:43

19/8/2006, 2:39

Send Email to paice30 Send PM to paice30

Durple
Purple fan
Global user

Registered: 09-2003
Posts: 1168

Reply | Quote

Re: Close This Whole Thread?

We're talking about the same things in every topic every now and then, so why close this one? If nobody's writing in this topic anymore, we can close it. But not as long as people write. If you don't like it, just keep away from it ;-)...

19/8/2006, 13:53

Send Email to Durple Send PM to Durple

DaveU
Purple fan
Global user

Registered: 05-2006
Posts: 376

Reply | Quote

Re: Close This Whole Thread?

I have a split opinion on this.

1. Keep it open until the next album comes out, then replace it with one for that album.

2. Why bother with threads for individual albums when there is a Reviews section.

On balance, I would go with option 1, but it's a close run thing.

22/8/2006, 11:03

Send Email to DaveU Send PM to DaveU

MachineHead 1
Talker of Total Bollocks
Global user

Registered: 09-2005
Posts: 1340

Reply | Quote

Re: Close This Whole Thread?

quote:
paice30 wrote:

I had a weak argument as to why to keep it open ... but decided I didn't have the onions to keep it on.

Why not keep it open?

My view is that as long as it is the current/latest studio album it deserves its place - and more so than other boards in the top section of the forum in my non-humble opinion (sorry Ed - I know you have copyright on that "non" prefix!!) emoticon

---
From the moment I heard the opening strains of Highway Star... that was it!!!
Machine Head blew me away
In Rock blew my brains out

22/8/2006, 16:24

Blog

Star City
Purple fan
Global user

Registered: 11-2005
Posts: 729

Reply | Quote

Re: Close This Whole Thread?

Its not a big deal...its just not getting much traffic...and the posts are usually....I love ROTD...I hate ROTD....I Love ROTD...I hate ROTD.....etc.

2/9/2006, 18:29

Send Email to Star City Send PM to Star City

MachineHead 1
Talker of Total Bollocks
Global user

Registered: 09-2005
Posts: 1340

Reply | Quote

Re: Close This Whole Thread?

quote:
Star City wrote:

Its not a big deal...its just not getting much traffic...and the posts are usually....I love ROTD...I hate ROTD....I Love ROTD...I hate ROTD.....etc.

True

---
From the moment I heard the opening strains of Highway Star... that was it!!!
Machine Head blew me away
In Rock blew my brains out

2/9/2006, 18:46

Blog

Milan Fahrnholz
Purple fan
Global user

Registered: 09-2003
Posts: 17840

Reply | Quote

Re: Close This Whole Thread?

quote:
Star City wrote:
Its not a big deal...its just not getting much traffic...and the posts are usually....I love ROTD...I hate ROTD....I Love ROTD...I hate ROTD.....etc.

Replace ROTD with DP and you can have an argument for closing the whole forum!
I don´t think that´s a reason to close the board.

6/9/2006, 20:32

Add a reply

You are not logged in (login) Board's time is: 1/12/2009, 4:14